Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Challenging Surveillance Cameras at Beaverhead County Dump Sites

DILLON, Mont. — A Montana District Court judge has dismissed a lawsuit challenging the installation of surveillance cameras at Beaverhead County's satellite dump stations, ruling that individuals do not have a legally reasonable expectation of privacy while using the public facilities.
On Tuesday, November 17, 2026, Fifth Judicial District Court Judge Luke Berger granted Beaverhead County's motion to dismiss a lawsuit filed by Chris Brozell against Beaverhead County Commissioners Tom Rice and Mike McGinley, along with Sheriff David Wendt.
The lawsuit challenged the county's use of surveillance cameras at its rural waste disposal locations, arguing that the cameras violated privacy protections under the Montana Constitution.

Lawsuit Filed Over Privacy Concerns
According to court documents, Brozell filed the complaint on September 24, 2026, representing himself without an attorney.
The complaint alleged that the county's installation of surveillance cameras at satellite dump stations violated Article II, Section 10 of the Montana Constitution, which protects the right to privacy.
Brozell argued that the county had not demonstrated a compelling state interest to justify the use of surveillance technology at the facilities.
The lawsuit sought removal of the cameras, a calculation of damages and a formal apology for the alleged invasion of privacy.

County Argued Public Dump Sites Carry No Reasonable Expectation of Privacy
On October 15, Beaverhead County filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit under Montana Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6).
The county argued that Brozell's complaint failed to establish a legally recognized privacy claim because individuals using public dump stations cannot reasonably expect their activities to remain private.
Brozell responded to the county's motion on October 29, maintaining that individuals visiting remote waste disposal sites alone could reasonably expect some level of privacy.
He also argued that the public had not been directly consulted about surveillance cameras at the dump stations and that a jury should determine whether their use was legitimate.
The county submitted its final reply on November 12.
Deputy County Attorneys John Gardner and Margot Newman represented the county in the proceedings.

Judge Rules Public Locations Do Not Provide the Same Privacy Protections
In his November 17 order, Judge Berger examined the legal standard for establishing a constitutional privacy violation.
Under Montana law, a person asserting a privacy claim must demonstrate both a subjective expectation of privacy and an expectation that society would recognize as objectively reasonable.
The court concluded that Brozell's decision to visit a rural dump station alone did not establish a legally reasonable expectation of privacy.
Judge Berger explained that although the facilities may be in rural locations, they remain public property accessible to other individuals at any time.
The court determined that individuals cannot expect the same degree of privacy in public places that they would have at their homes or on private property.
The judge also acknowledged that Brozell might be uncomfortable with surveillance cameras at the dump stations but concluded that this discomfort did not establish a constitutional privacy claim.

Court Grants County's Motion to Dismiss
Following its review of the arguments and applicable Montana case law, the court ruled in favor of Beaverhead County.
The order states:
"The County's Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED."
Judge Berger electronically signed the ruling on November 17, 2026, at 2:03 p.m.
The court also directed the Clerk of Court to distribute copies of the order to the parties involved.
What the Ruling Means
The decision dismisses Brozell's lawsuit on the grounds that the complaint did not establish a legally protected expectation of privacy at the public dump stations.
The ruling does not establish that every possible use of surveillance technology by a government agency is constitutional. Rather, it addresses the specific privacy claim presented in this case.
The court's order does not direct Beaverhead County to remove the surveillance cameras or award damages to the plaintiff.





Comments